This Is The Deep | Ranny Macdonald on ‘Everything’ and the Whale That Ate Itself
London collective This Is The Deep have released ‘Everything (Dick Herman, The Whale, and The End Of The Beginning)’, an album about a man who falls asleep at his desk and finds himself in a series of increasingly strange dreams.
We spoke with the group’s founder, Ranny Macdonald, about the six years it took to put together, the musicians involved and the rather unusual story behind it.
Dick Herman works for Telepix, a fictional social media company. One day he falls asleep at work and dreams he’s on a beach. Before long, he’s heading into the sea, where he encounters a whale with an appetite so enormous that it eventually eats itself. Some of the songs deal with relationships, others with creativity, technology and the way we treat the natural world.
This Is The Deep began with friends making recordings beneath the railway arches in Bethnal Green. These days it’s a much larger affair, bringing together musicians from different backgrounds, including several members of Macdonald’s own family. Harp, violin, brass and strings sit alongside the guitars, drums and keyboards, while Macdonald’s paintings and other visual work have become an important part of the project.
Released on November 11 through 5dB Records, ‘Everything’ was largely self-produced, with additional production from SHOLTO and Patrick Fitzroy. We featured ‘I’m Making’ back in August, when the band first announced the album. We spoke with Macdonald about the music, the paintings that helped inspire it and the six years he spent bringing the whole thing together.
“Everything starts with playing and reaching into silence and emptiness to see what you pull out.”
I read that the band started with friends making recordings in a little studio under the railway arches in Bethnal Green. It sounds a world away from the 8–10-piece you are now. Do you still work in that same loose, spontaneous way, or has making a record of this size changed things quite a bit?
Ranny Macdonald: I find usually when I make something there’s two phases, the loose spontaneous one where you get the broad strokes, 70/80% of the idea down very quickly and the slower more deliberate final stages, which might take a lot longer. With these recordings they were almost all started in that same way, recording a few instruments live spontaneously in a studio and afterwards taking the projects away and meeting up with different friends and recording them individually.
I have to ask, where on earth did Dick Herman come from? He’s hardly the most obvious character to build an album around! Did you have his whole underwater adventure worked out before writing the songs, or did the story gradually come together as you went along?
It’s not particularly easy to put into words but I felt the whole thing brewing, and it emerged slowly over a 6-year period. Everything starts with playing and reaching into silence and emptiness to see what you pull out. When the process started I found my research in philosophy, ecology, art, and Taoism bled into what I wrote. As well as this, I had older songs, and more personal songs, about relationships too. I was curious if there could be a way to bring them all together and create a kind of geography for the record as I had a song about a beach and a sketch of something about a whale – and the idea of a dream sequence of a character arrived, where the sea could be like a visualization of the character’s subconscious. There’s quite a lot about technology, the digital, so I wanted that to feature in this character’s life too, hence his position in Telepix. It happened a bit like that… I’m glad he’s not the most obvious character to build an album around though – obvious doesn’t sound very fun!
A few years ago, you described ‘Glass’ as a song about people overreaching. Now you’ve got a whale that keeps consuming everything until it eventually eats itself. Is this something you’ve been thinking about for a long time? And where did the idea of the whale actually come from?
Yes, it has. I think there’s something human and universal in that story, but also something about it that relates specifically to our culture. One with too much Yang, not enough Yin, you could say – or too much warrior-mind, not enough mother-mind. The Whale is a visualization of this unbalance in a way. It’s something I recognise externally and feel the effect of internally, in a way the song is about recognising and trying to deal with that in some way, once the whale eats itself the sea lets out a sigh of relief, so there’s a kind of harmony at the end of the tale.
The idea started after I saw an artwork by a friend at The Slade School of Art where I studied, of a kind of big white blob with these sad eyes. It looked like a whale to me and I was already painting these anthropomorphic characters, thinking about human/nature relationships and western ideology, and I thought, ‘yeah that could work, a whale, like Moby Dick’ so I started making drawings, from which I made a model and paintings. I then started writing a song, I probably wouldn’t have developed it any further but my sister’s boyfriend at the time, an artist called Mark Connolly, who I was living with, came back one night and heard me messing around with the song on the piano and persuaded me to keep going with it. So I did.
‘I’m Making’ goes off in all sorts of musical directions, but there’s still a really strong song underneath it all. I’m curious how you put something like that together. Do you usually come in with a fairly clear idea, or does everyone start adding things until the song takes on a life of its own?
I remember exactly where the idea for ‘I’m Making’ came from. It was in lockdown, I was finishing my art BA online and painting in a little 4 by 5 ft conservatory at my parents’ house, which was an entrance to a back door which didn’t get used. I was making a series called ‘Up in the Air’ of cactuses and all kinds of things being uprooted and blown about. I felt like I had made a little cocoon for myself and was quite happy about it and in a kind of silly mood so I started singing ‘I’m making… Making a mess’. It was a long time before I put any music to it or showed anyone. I would just let the idea percolate and kept singing it to myself when I’d go on walks, starting to hear this Walter Murphy beat to it and crazy fills. When we did come to record it, we did three takes with drums, guitar, bass, and vocals and that was pretty much it, Rachel’s harp worked really well to offset the kind of garage rock groove we had and Clem made a beautiful string arrangement, we were thinking about tango strings.
I find ‘Never Easy’ interesting because, in the middle of all these strange dreams and underwater adventures, there’s suddenly something very familiar: two people trying and failing to understand each other. Why did you want to bring that part of Dick Herman’s past into the story?
I thought if these were dreams there would be some dreams of past loves, relationships that have gone wrong so it felt like it worked.
You’ve got quite a collection of musicians in the band, with harp, violin, brass and everything else going on. What were the recording sessions actually like? You produced much of the album yourselves, with SHOLTO and Patrick Fitzroy also involved. Did the songs change much once everyone started playing together?
The songs develop throughout the process. I would turn up to Oscar and Dave’s studio, who worked on most of the production, with a song and we’d think about the structure and cut a rhythm track with live bass, drums, a scratch vocal we might end up using, and keys and guitar, sometimes percussion too. From there we’d try stuff out on it and build some ideas and then I would usually take the project and work on it more at home and travel to different musicians like Clem who plays violin or my sister Alice who sings lead on ‘This Tender Place’ and a lot of BVs and work with them one on one. The whale started off as more of a sea shanty upright piano thing and ended up more techno song. You just never know…
I love that you’ve taken the visual side of the band so far. Even in the early days you were making these enormous underwater paintings for your shows, and now apparently there are inflatable whales, rafts and dancers involved! Who comes up with all these ideas, and has anyone ever had to say, ‘Hang on, how are we actually going to pull this off?’
OK so to clarify some of these are things we are hoping to do. This Is The Deep was intended to bridge music and visual art, so just as music develops, the story and the visual ideas develop too. I do have crazy ideas and usually it’s our label who say if they’re too crazy. Dancers, the raft onstage will all be for the future and dependent on bigger stages and budgets, but we do have an inflatable whale costume on the go we’re making with a friend, costume designer called Ruth Valeria, which we’re really excited to unveil at our next show on the 20th of Nov at OSLO Hackney.

One last thing I’m curious about. If Dick Herman ever makes it back to his desk at Telepix, do you think he’ll have learned anything from his adventure, or will he just check his messages and carry on as before?
This is the question to which there isn’t one answer but it’s for the listener to decide. I am at heart an optimist so I think, yes, he will have learnt a lot. Let’s see… we might not have seen the last of him.
Klemen Breznikar
Headline credit: James Barrat
This Is The Deep Instagram / Bandcamp



